Capital markets: A key weakness for Europe compared to the United States

As a result, Europe continues to rely heavily on the banking sector as its primary source of financing, leaving companies vulnerable to significant risks in times of crisis—such as the fallout from the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers in 2008. This stands in stark contrast to the efficiency of the capital markets in the United States, a disparity that has become even more apparent amid the current uncertainties over the new Trump era.

At the close of the first quarter of 2024, credit to the private sector (households and businesses) represented 150.4% of GDP in the Eurozone, with 82.9% of this credit coming from the banking sector. In the United States, where access to capital markets is far more advanced, these figures stood at 149.9% and 48.9% of GDP, respectively—a marked difference that is also evident when compared to other countries and regions around the globe.

In a recent report on Credit and Insurance Activity, MAPFRE Economics, MAPFRE’s research arm noted the consequences of Europe’s heavy reliance on bank credit. “This reliance limits the financing options available to companies and households in the European Union, particularly SMEs, which face greater barriers to growth and adjustment. Unlike in the United States, SMEs in Europe lack access to alternative sources of finance, especially during financial crises when bank credit typically tightens.”

For this reason, advancing the CMU is imperative. According to the experts at MAPFRE Economics, “the lack of a robust alternative in the European capital market limits the ability of companies to secure the funding they need to innovate and grow. This gap undermines Europe’s ability to attract and retain innovative, high-growth companies, often driving them to seek financing abroad or even relocate their operations to more developed capital markets, such as the United States.”

This dynamic leads to a substantial loss of innovative potential and competitiveness for the European Union, as well as a drain of talent and capital that could otherwise strengthen the region’s economic ecosystem. A recent Draghi report warned that the EU needs up to €800 billion of investment to close the gap with the United States and China.

At the same time, the slow progress of the CMU has also meant that Europe is missing out on opportunities in sustainable finance—a critical sector for the European Union and its climate objectives. “Without a unified capital market, the ability to issue sustainable bonds in a uniform and accessible manner is limited, affecting the financing of environmental and digital transition projects, key pillars of the European Green Deal, among other initiatives,” added the experts at MAPFRE Economics.

In conclusion, these challenges highlight the pressing need for greater integration within the European capital market. The lack of progress not only undermines the region’s economic competitiveness but also restricts its ability to respond effectively to crises and sustain long-term growth.

Click here to read the full report